Captains Choice Bay Rum Aftershave

  • Captains Choice Bay Rum Aftershave
  • Captains Choice Bay Rum After shave

BAY RUM Aftershave

by Captains Choice
$17.95

Preserved in its classic amber bottle, Captain’s Choice Aftershave is unparalleled with its invigorating, superior all natural formula.  It is made with pure grain alcohol, witch hazel and essential oils and extracts providing you with a warm light tingle followed by a soothing sensation. 

Out of stock
Size: 4 oz
Notify me when this product is in stock:
Email:
Please specify a valid email address

With Captain’s Choice Aftershave your skin is guaranteed to feel soft, and moisturized while smelling fantastic throughout the entire day.  Available in Bay Rum, Cat O’ Nine Tails and Lime.  

How to use

Shake well and apply a liberal amount to face and neck after shaving.

 

Benefits

Made with the finest all-natural ingredients

Essential oils and extracts help to alleviate skin

Keeps skin moisturized and smelling fresh throughout the day

Ingredients

Alcohol, witch hazel, essential oils and extracts, glycerin.

  1. Captain's Choice Bay Rum Review by Bill
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    Captain's Choice is the best bay rum on the market . If you want to smell great than this is the only one to buy. I get so many compliments that my wife get mad when I am asked what cologne you are wearing. I tell them it is not a cologne but my aftershave. Captain's Choice. (Posted on 6/3/2016)

  2. Amazing Aftershave! Review by Wired360
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    Tried it for the first time, and now I understand why its so popular! Love the smell, has a nice burn and it lasts for quite a while! Also not to mention it smells very nice! (Posted on 11/7/2014)

  3. Balanced and manly Review by Chris
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    Captain's choice is my favorite iteration of bay rum I've come across so far. In the bottle, it is rough and smells of alcohol. Don't let that fool you. Apply it and it goes on smooth with minimal burn and smells great! The scent is balanced; spicy and manly without being too aggressive. This aftershave won't dry out your skin and the scent is persistent. Great quality product, takes a hit on uniqueness only because it is a very popular scent to produce across brands, and has a respectable price point. (Posted on 11/2/2014)

  4. Great Aftershave Review by Dustin
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    This smells great and doesn't dry out my face like the cheaper aftershaves I've used. It doesn't burn very much when I put it on but leaves a soothing warm sensation that lingers for awhile. The scent left on my face was subtle but smelled great. I would definitely recommend this to anyone looking for a good manly aftershave. (Posted on 10/29/2014)

  5. I love CC!! Review by Tyler
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    Captain's choice lime has been one of my go to aftershaves for a while now. I really enjoy the bay rum scent too, especially in the cooler months of the year. This aftershave has a nice little burn and leaves my skin feeling toned and moisturized. However, some folks may find it a bit drying due to the alcohol content. (Posted on 10/27/2014)

  6. Simply the best! Review by William
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    Of all the Bay Rum aftershaves on the market Captains Choice is the only one I will purchase. This Bay Rum scent is what all others are trying to imitate and the cool feeling on your skin is unmatched. (Posted on 10/16/2014)

  7. Nice Bay Rum Review by Pete
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    I've never been a big fan of Bay Rum, but after receiving this and some matching soap, I found it was much better scented than others. I decided to try it and it's a nice AS. The scent calms down quickly and does last. I can't see me buying this again though. (Posted on 8/12/2014)

  8. The smell is just one of a kind Review by Bill
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    I have no idea how to describe this smell, I've never smelt anything like it! Simply amazing! Captain's Choice doesn't disappoint and with their Bay Rum scent, you'll be blown away and hooked for life! (Posted on 8/11/2014)

  9. Bay Rum and a Smack in the face Review by Paul
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    Captain's Choice Bay Rum Review


    I can see why the Captain is the favorite of many. It's a solid performer that will let you know if your technique needs improving, while providing very good skin care after the burn fades.

    I really like the scent and skincare provided by this aftershave, but the burn is not to my taste. Many really enjoy the burn, which increases in intensity as shave technique lags. The company even makes a version with more burn - Cat O' Nine Tails. I think I'll skip that one! Thankfully, the burn only lasts a few minutes, as the product dries down to a subtle sweetness that does not interfere with colognes or EdTs. The scent is sweet and not cloven, and it matches their excellent RazoRock croap nicely.

    The only other bay rum I've used extensively is Krampert's Finest Acadian, and I must say that I prefer it's lack of burn and skin feeling. This is not to say that I don't like Captain's Choice, but rather that it comes in second for me. Anyone who like the burn will clearly reverse my ranking.

    Packaging: 9/10 for the brown glass bottle and cool label design
    Scent: 9/10 - excellent scent, perhaps a little sweeter than some
    Skincare: 7/10 - great alcohol burn for those seeking it, after cool down, the face is left smooth and not tight or greasy.  (Posted on 7/14/2014)

  10. What Bay Rum "should" smell like Review by Richard
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    I'll be the first to admit that Bay Rum has always been just an 'ok' scent to me. It also puzzled me that a fragrance could be SO different depending on where you got the product from.

    When I tried CC's Bay Rum (actually initially as a small sample) I was very impressed. This was by far the most 'balanced' bay rum scent I had come across. There is some spiciness to it but it doesn't go overboard.

    If I would wish for anything it's that the scent would linger for a tad longer. It seems to be completely gone within about 8-10 mins for me.

    A very nice after shave product. (Posted on 7/4/2014)

  11. Best bay rum bar none! Review by Jason
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    If you like bay rum, you'll love CC. The scent is very old school and your face will be feeling fresh after you apply. Absolutely worth a little extra for this great aftershave. (Posted on 6/27/2014)

  12. Bay Rum AS at its finest Review by Orion
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    If you have bay rum then you should get this AS
    This is what bay rum should smell like.
    Warm and spicy and not too sweet. (and all natural as well)

    Buy this AS and you will not be disappointed. (Posted on 6/26/2014)

  13. My goto bay rum! Review by Brian
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    I really like Captains Choice! This bay rum scent is very nice! There are no cloves, like some cheaper brands, and all natural ingredients! What's not to love? Get some, you'll love it too! (Posted on 6/10/2014)

  14. Best bang for your buck. Review by Brandon
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    This is a high quality aftershave at a very fair price. Captain's Choice bay rum is one my favorite bay rum scents. It has a mild but pleasant burn and leaves your face feeling great for hours after application. I've used more expensive aftershaves that don't compare to Captain's Choice. (Posted on 6/10/2014)

  15. Awesome, great smelling! Buy some Review by Steven
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    Awesome aftershave, I find that it has a nice scent that lasts a good while. Nice burn, but more moisturizers would be nice as a personal preference.

    Buy some
    (Posted on 6/7/2014)

  16. Classic bay rum Review by Brian
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    This is straight up, classic bay rum. For those not familiar with the scent, it smells primarily of cinnamon and clove. This stuff is well made. You get a lot in a bottle and a little bit goes a long way. This scent won't linger all day on your skin, but it'll do a fine job of soothing post shave irritation. (Posted on 6/3/2014)

  17. All that you need for a great shave experience! Review by Christian
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    You can't go wrong with bay rum, and this stuff is no exception! My brother uses this stuff and let me try some once, and I must say that it is my favorite scent of aftershave. It leaves your face feeling perfect, warm, and is just a great all-out scent. Recommended by me! (Posted on 6/2/2014)

  18. a great bay rum Review by Chuck
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    Excellent bay-focused bay rum scent with orange and cinnamon in there, too. And very good performance as an aftershave. (Posted on 5/30/2014)

  19. Amazing clove=less bay rum! Review by Mitchell
    Quality
    Uniqueness
    Value

    This really is my favourite bay rum, and it's pretty unqiue as well.

    The scent you'll find is warm and spicy, gives a bit of bite after shaving.

    There are two types of bay rum. Some have cloves, others do not. The second category is much smaller than the first.

    If you've smelled Pinaud's bay rum for instance, that is clove heavy. It reminds me of christmas trees, though still spicy.

    This removes that tree-like scent. So it's just warm and spicy, with the natural bay scent.

    Lovely stuff, and a little bit goes a long way. (Posted on 5/29/2014)


Write Your Own Review

You're reviewing: BAY RUM Aftershave

How do you rate this product? *

  1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars
Quality
Uniqueness
Value
Google Analytics Alternative